AI Card Bao AR02.AICARDBAO.COM

Industry News

The General Legal Counsel of the European Court of Justice emphasizes: Model training is acceptable, but bypassing payment barriers or simply copying existing expressions is not allowed.

The case in which a Hungarian website operator sued Google has recently reached a critical stage. The Legal Advisor to the European Court of Justice issued an official opinion, clarifying the boundaries regarding how Gemini may use news content.

This opinion provides explanations from both perspectives.

The advantage for AI companies is that copyright laws do not protect the mere facts contained in news reports; instead, they only cover the specific ways these facts are presented. It is not considered illegal for algorithms to extract and summarize such facts. Additionally, exceptions related to text and data mining allow the use of copyrighted materials to train large-scale models, as long as such practices comply with relevant regulations.

From the publisher's perspective: If Gemini illegally circumvents paywalls to access content, or if it reproduces specific phrases from news reports in a way that is easily recognizable in its responses, it may be infringing upon the publisher's rights regarding reproduction.

The criteria for evaluation focus on two aspects: “output” and “method of acquisition.” The training process is relatively safe; questions regarding the appearance of the results or the source of the data can be answered openly, as these details must withstand scrutiny.

This will have a significant impact on the engineering efforts of model companies. If the judgment is implemented in this way, it will be necessary to control the similarity between generated responses and the original text. Moreover, when conducting data scraping operations, paid walls must be taken seriously; otherwise, those data pipelines that rely on “scraping first and dealing with the consequences later” will face significant risks.

Opinions themselves do not have direct legal binding force; however, judges generally take them into consideration when reaching their final decisions.

The media shouldn’t get too excited just yet. This recommendation doesn’t address the most critical issue: the use of AI in summarizing news articles actually keeps readers within those dialogue boxes, resulting in a decline in both traffic and advertising revenue for news websites. As long as AI rephrases the facts in a different way, this approach doesn’t violate any regulations. Although publishers may win this legal battle, they are unlikely to regain the lost clicks as a result of this practice.

Related